The ability to scale out training workloads has been one of the key performance enablers of deep learning. The main scaling approach is data-parallel GPU-based training, which has been boosted by hardware and software support for highly efficient inter-GPU communication, in particular via bandwidth overprovisioning. This support comes at a price: there is an order of magnitude cost difference between "cloud-grade" servers with such support, relative to their "consumer-grade" counterparts, although server-grade and consumer-grade GPUs can have similar computational envelopes. In this paper, we investigate whether the expensive hardware overprovisioning approach can be supplanted via algorithmic and system design, and propose a framework called CGX, which provides efficient software support for communication compression. We show that this framework is able to remove communication bottlenecks from consumer-grade multi-GPU systems, in the absence of hardware support: when training modern models and tasks to full accuracy, our framework enables self-speedups of 2-3X on a commodity system using 8 consumer-grade NVIDIA RTX 3090 GPUs, and enables it to surpass the throughput of an NVIDIA DGX-1 server, which has similar peak FLOPS but benefits from bandwidth overprovisioning.