We present new multi-test Bayesian optimization models and algorithms for use in large scale material screening applications. Our screening problems are designed around two tests, one expensive and one cheap. This paper differs from other recent work on multi-test Bayesian optimization through use of a flexible model that allows for complex, non-linear relationships between the cheap and expensive test scores. This additional modeling flexibility is essential in the material screening applications which we describe. We demonstrate the power of our new algorithms on a family of synthetic toy problems as well as on real data from two large scale screening studies.