In this work, we experimentally determined the efficacy of several classes of proton donors for lithium-mediated electrochemical nitrogen reduction in a tetrahydrofuran-based electrolyte, an attractive alternative method for producing ammonia. We then built an interpretable data-driven classification model which identified solvatochromic Kamlet-Taft parameters as important for distinguishing between active and inactive proton donors. After curating a dataset for the Kamlet-Taft parameters, we trained a deep learning model to predict the Kamlet-Taft parameters. The combination of classification model and deep learning model provides a predictive mapping from a given proton donor to the ability to produce ammonia. We demonstrate that this combination of classification model with deep learning is superior to a purely mechanistic or data-driven approach in accuracy and experimental data efficiency.