Purpose: To evaluate diagnostic utility of two convolutional neural networks (CNNs) for severity staging anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injuries. Materials and Methods: This retrospective analysis was conducted on 1243 knee MR images (1008 intact, 18 partially torn, 77 fully torn, 140 reconstructed ACLs) from 224 subjects collected between 2011 and 2014 (age=46.50+\-13.55 years, body mass index=24.58+\-3.60 kg/m2, 46% women (mean+\-standard deviation). Images were acquired with a 3.0T MR scanner using 3D fast spin echo CUBE-sequences. The radiologists used a modified scoring metric analagous to the ACLOAS and WORMS for grading standard. To classify ACL injuries with deep learning, two types of CNNs were used, one with three-dimensional (3D) and the other with two-dimensional (2D) convolutional kernels. Performance metrics included sensitivity, specificity, weighted Cohen's kappa, and overall accuracy, followed by two-sample t-tests to compare CNN performance. Results: The overall accuracy (84%) and weighted Cohen's kappa (.92) reported for ACL injury classification were higher using the 2D CNN than the 3D CNN. The 2D CNN and 3D CNN performed similarly in assessing intact ACLs (2D CNN: 93% sensitivity and 90% specificity, 3D CNN: 89% sensitivity and 88% specificity). Classification of full tears by both networks were also comparable (2D CNN: 83% sensitivity and 94% specificity, 3D CNN: 77% sensitivity and 100% sensitivity). The 2D CNN classified all reconstructed ACLs correctly. Conclusion: CNNs applied to ACL lesion classification results in high sensitivity and specificity, leading to potential use in helping grade ACL injuries by non-experts.