We present a style-transfer based wrapper, called Universal Material Generator (UMG), to improve the generalization performance of any fingerprint spoof detector against spoofs made from materials not seen during training. Specifically, we transfer the style (texture) characteristics between fingerprint images of known materials with the goal of synthesizing fingerprint images corresponding to unknown materials, that may occupy the space between the known materials in the deep feature space. Synthetic live fingerprint images are also added to the training dataset to force the CNN to learn generative-noise invariant features which discriminate between lives and spoofs. The proposed approach is shown to improve the generalization performance of a state-of-the-art spoof detector, namely Fingerprint Spoof Buster, from TDR of 75.24% to 91.78% @ FDR = 0.2%. These results are based on a large-scale dataset of 5,743 live and 4,912 spoof images fabricated using 12 different materials. Additionally, the UMG wrapper is shown to improve the average cross-sensor spoof detection performance from 67.60% to 80.63% when tested on the LivDet 2017 dataset. Training the UMG wrapper requires only 100 live fingerprint images from the target sensor, alleviating the time and resources required to generate large-scale live and spoof datasets for a new sensor. We also fabricate physical spoof artifacts using a mixture of known spoof materials to explore the role of cross-material style transfer in improving generalization performance.