Given a binary prediction problem, which performance metric should the classifier optimize? We address this question by formalizing the problem of metric elicitation. In particular, we focus on eliciting binary performance metrics from pairwise preferences, where users provide relative feedback for pairs of classifiers. By exploiting key properties of the space of confusion matrices, we obtain provably query efficient algorithms for eliciting linear and linear-fractional metrics. We further show that our method is robust to feedback and finite sample noise.