Continuous vector representations of words and objects appear to carry surprisingly rich semantic content. In this paper, we advance both the conceptual and theoretical understanding of word embeddings in three ways. First, we ground embeddings in semantic spaces studied in cognitive-psychometric literature and introduce new evaluation tasks. Second, in contrast to prior work, we take metric recovery as the key object of study, unify existing algorithms as consistent metric recovery methods based on co-occurrence counts from simple Markov random walks, and propose a new recovery algorithm. Third, we generalize metric recovery to graphs and manifolds, relating co-occurence counts on random walks in graphs and random processes on manifolds to the underlying metric to be recovered, thereby reconciling manifold estimation and embedding algorithms. We compare embedding algorithms across a range of tasks, from nonlinear dimensionality reduction to three semantic language tasks, including analogies, sequence completion, and classification.