The performance of EM in learning mixtures of product distributions often depends on the initialization. This can be problematic in crowdsourcing and other applications, e.g. when a small number of 'experts' are diluted by a large number of noisy, unreliable participants. We develop a new EM algorithm that is driven by these experts. In a manner that differs from other approaches, we start from a single mixture class. The algorithm then develops the set of 'experts' in a stagewise fashion based on a mutual information criterion. At each stage EM operates on this subset of the players, effectively regularizing the E rather than the M step. Experiments show that stagewise EM outperforms other initialization techniques for crowdsourcing and neurosciences applications, and can guide a full EM to results comparable to those obtained knowing the exact distribution.