Are Neural Architecture Search Benchmarks Well Designed? A Deeper Look Into Operation Importance

Neural Architecture Search (NAS) benchmarks significantly improved the capability of developing and comparing NAS methods while at the same time drastically reduced the computational overhead by providing meta-information about thousands of trained neural networks. However, tabular benchmarks have several drawbacks that can hinder fair comparisons and provide unreliable results. These usually focus on providing a small pool of operations in heavily constrained search spaces -- usually cell-based neural networks with pre-defined outer-skeletons. In this work, we conducted an empirical analysis of the widely used NAS-Bench-101, NAS-Bench-201 and TransNAS-Bench-101 benchmarks in terms of their generability and how different operations influence the performance of the generated architectures. We found that only a subset of the operation pool is required to generate architectures close to the upper-bound of the performance range. Also, the performance distribution is negatively skewed, having a higher density of architectures in the upper-bound range. We consistently found convolution layers to have the highest impact on the architecture's performance, and that specific combination of operations favors top-scoring architectures. These findings shed insights on the correct evaluation and comparison of NAS methods using NAS benchmarks, showing that directly searching on NAS-Bench-201, ImageNet16-120 and TransNAS-Bench-101 produces more reliable results than searching only on CIFAR-10. Furthermore, with this work we provide suggestions for future benchmark evaluations and design. The code used to conduct the evaluations is available at https://github.com/VascoLopes/NAS-Benchmark-Evaluation.

Towards Less Constrained Macro-Neural Architecture Search

Networks found with Neural Architecture Search (NAS) achieve state-of-the-art performance in a variety of tasks, out-performing human-designed networks. However, most NAS methods heavily rely on human-defined assumptions that constrain the search: architecture's outer-skeletons, number of layers, parameter heuristics and search spaces. Additionally, common search spaces consist of repeatable modules (cells) instead of fully exploring the architecture's search space by designing entire architectures (macro-search). Imposing such constraints requires deep human expertise and restricts the search to pre-defined settings. In this paper, we propose LCMNAS, a method that pushes NAS to less constrained search spaces by performing macro-search without relying on pre-defined heuristics or bounded search spaces. LCMNAS introduces three components for the NAS pipeline: i) a method that leverages information about well-known architectures to autonomously generate complex search spaces based on Weighted Directed Graphs with hidden properties, ii) a evolutionary search strategy that generates complete architectures from scratch, and iii) a mixed-performance estimation approach that combines information about architectures at initialization stage and lower fidelity estimates to infer their trainability and capacity to model complex functions. We present experiments showing that LCMNAS generates state-of-the-art architectures from scratch with minimal GPU computation. We study the importance of different NAS components on a macro-search setting. Code for reproducibility is public at \url{https://github.com/VascoLopes/LCMNAS}.

Guided Evolution for Neural Architecture Search

Neural Architecture Search (NAS) methods have been successfully applied to image tasks with excellent results. However, NAS methods are often complex and tend to converge to local minima as soon as generated architectures seem to yield good results. In this paper, we propose G-EA, a novel approach for guided evolutionary NAS. The rationale behind G-EA, is to explore the search space by generating and evaluating several architectures in each generation at initialization stage using a zero-proxy estimator, where only the highest-scoring network is trained and kept for the next generation. This evaluation at initialization stage allows continuous extraction of knowledge from the search space without increasing computation, thus allowing the search to be efficiently guided. Moreover, G-EA forces exploitation of the most performant networks by descendant generation while at the same time forcing exploration by parent mutation and by favouring younger architectures to the detriment of older ones. Experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed method, showing that G-EA achieves state-of-the-art results in NAS-Bench-201 search space in CIFAR-10, CIFAR-100 and ImageNet16-120, with mean accuracies of 93.98%, 72.12% and 45.94% respectively.

Generative Adversarial Graph Convolutional Networks for Human Action Synthesis

Synthesising the spatial and temporal dynamics of the human body skeleton remains a challenging task, not only in terms of the quality of the generated shapes, but also of their diversity, particularly to synthesise realistic body movements of a specific action (action conditioning). In this paper, we propose Kinetic-GAN, a novel architecture that leverages the benefits of Generative Adversarial Networks and Graph Convolutional Networks to synthesise the kinetics of the human body. The proposed adversarial architecture can condition up to 120 different actions over local and global body movements while improving sample quality and diversity through latent space disentanglement and stochastic variations. Our experiments were carried out in three well-known datasets, where Kinetic-GAN notably surpasses the state-of-the-art methods in terms of distribution quality metrics while having the ability to synthesise more than one order of magnitude regarding the number of different actions. Our code and models are publicly available at https://github.com/DegardinBruno/Kinetic-GAN.

REGINA - Reasoning Graph Convolutional Networks in Human Action Recognition

It is known that the kinematics of the human body skeleton reveals valuable information in action recognition. Recently, modeling skeletons as spatio-temporal graphs with Graph Convolutional Networks (GCNs) has been reported to solidly advance the state-of-the-art performance. However, GCN-based approaches exclusively learn from raw skeleton data, and are expected to extract the inherent structural information on their own. This paper describes REGINA, introducing a novel way to REasoning Graph convolutional networks IN Human Action recognition. The rationale is to provide to the GCNs additional knowledge about the skeleton data, obtained by handcrafted features, in order to facilitate the learning process, while guaranteeing that it remains fully trainable in an end-to-end manner. The challenge is to capture complementary information over the dynamics between consecutive frames, which is the key information extracted by state-of-the-art GCN techniques. Moreover, the proposed strategy can be easily integrated in the existing GCN-based methods, which we also regard positively. Our experiments were carried out in well known action recognition datasets and enabled to conclude that REGINA contributes for solid improvements in performance when incorporated to other GCN-based approaches, without any other adjustment regarding the original method. For reproducibility, the REGINA code and all the experiments carried out will be publicly available at https://github.com/DegardinBruno.

EPE-NAS: Efficient Performance Estimation Without Training for Neural Architecture Search

Neural Architecture Search (NAS) has shown excellent results in designing architectures for computer vision problems. NAS alleviates the need for human-defined settings by automating architecture design and engineering. However, NAS methods tend to be slow, as they require large amounts of GPU computation. This bottleneck is mainly due to the performance estimation strategy, which requires the evaluation of the generated architectures, mainly by training them, to update the sampler method. In this paper, we propose EPE-NAS, an efficient performance estimation strategy, that mitigates the problem of evaluating networks, by scoring untrained networks and creating a correlation with their trained performance. We perform this process by looking at intra and inter-class correlations of an untrained network. We show that EPE-NAS can produce a robust correlation and that by incorporating it into a simple random sampling strategy, we are able to search for competitive networks, without requiring any training, in a matter of seconds using a single GPU. Moreover, EPE-NAS is agnostic to the search method, since it focuses on the evaluation of untrained networks, making it easy to integrate into almost any NAS method.

An AutoML-based Approach to Multimodal Image Sentiment Analysis

Sentiment analysis is a research topic focused on analysing data to extract information related to the sentiment that it causes. Applications of sentiment analysis are wide, ranging from recommendation systems, and marketing to customer satisfaction. Recent approaches evaluate textual content using Machine Learning techniques that are trained over large corpora. However, as social media grown, other data types emerged in large quantities, such as images. Sentiment analysis in images has shown to be a valuable complement to textual data since it enables the inference of the underlying message polarity by creating context and connections. Multimodal sentiment analysis approaches intend to leverage information of both textual and image content to perform an evaluation. Despite recent advances, current solutions still flounder in combining both image and textual information to classify social media data, mainly due to subjectivity, inter-class homogeneity and fusion data differences. In this paper, we propose a method that combines both textual and image individual sentiment analysis into a final fused classification based on AutoML, that performs a random search to find the best model. Our method achieved state-of-the-art performance in the B-T4SA dataset, with 95.19% accuracy.

Auto-Classifier: A Robust Defect Detector Based on an AutoML Head

The dominant approach for surface defect detection is the use of hand-crafted feature-based methods. However, this falls short when conditions vary that affect extracted images. So, in this paper, we sought to determine how well several state-of-the-art Convolutional Neural Networks perform in the task of surface defect detection. Moreover, we propose two methods: CNN-Fusion, that fuses the prediction of all the networks into a final one, and Auto-Classifier, which is a novel proposal that improves a Convolutional Neural Network by modifying its classification component using AutoML. We carried out experiments to evaluate the proposed methods in the task of surface defect detection using different datasets from DAGM2007. We show that the use of Convolutional Neural Networks achieves better results than traditional methods, and also, that Auto-Classifier out-performs all other methods, by achieving 100% accuracy and 100% AUC results throughout all the datasets.

HMCNAS: Neural Architecture Search using Hidden Markov Chains and Bayesian Optimization

Neural Architecture Search has achieved state-of-the-art performance in a variety of tasks, out-performing human-designed networks. However, many assumptions, that require human definition, related with the problems being solved or the models generated are still needed: final model architectures, number of layers to be sampled, forced operations, small search spaces, which ultimately contributes to having models with higher performances at the cost of inducing bias into the system. In this paper, we propose HMCNAS, which is composed of two novel components: i) a method that leverages information about human-designed models to autonomously generate a complex search space, and ii) an Evolutionary Algorithm with Bayesian Optimization that is capable of generating competitive CNNs from scratch, without relying on human-defined parameters or small search spaces. The experimental results show that the proposed approach results in competitive architectures obtained in a very short time. HMCNAS provides a step towards generalizing NAS, by providing a way to create competitive models, without requiring any human knowledge about the specific task.

A Hybrid Method for Training Convolutional Neural Networks

Artificial Intelligence algorithms have been steadily increasing in popularity and usage. Deep Learning, allows neural networks to be trained using huge datasets and also removes the need for human extracted features, as it automates the feature learning process. In the hearth of training deep neural networks, such as Convolutional Neural Networks, we find backpropagation, that by computing the gradient of the loss function with respect to the weights of the network for a given input, it allows the weights of the network to be adjusted to better perform in the given task. In this paper, we propose a hybrid method that uses both backpropagation and evolutionary strategies to train Convolutional Neural Networks, where the evolutionary strategies are used to help to avoid local minimas and fine-tune the weights, so that the network achieves higher accuracy results. We show that the proposed hybrid method is capable of improving upon regular training in the task of image classification in CIFAR-10, where a VGG16 model was used and the final test results increased 0.61%, in average, when compared to using only backpropagation.